Can I Make Pickled Eggs by Putting Boiled Eggs in Pickle Juice?

by Andrea Lott

Pickle enthusiasts buy the large jar of the tasty delights, eat them all, and feel just a little sad about pouring all of the leftover liquid goodness down the drain. Luckily, that pickle juice can be reused to create pickled eggs, good for snacks, appetizers, or on a salad. Make pickled eggs by putting boiled eggs in pickle juice and make the most of a refrigerator staple.

Pickling uses acid, salt and seasonings to react with foods, preserving them and altering the flavor. Acid inhibits the growth of some bacteria, making foods preserved this way less prone to spoiling. Leftover pickle juice already contains the acid, usually vinegar or beet juice, and seasonings needed for pickling eggs. Pickled eggs stay edible in the refrigerator up to several weeks when properly prepared. Over time, the pickled flavor develops more fully as it seeps into the layers of peeled hard boiled egg.

When picking the perfect eggs to pickle, choose small or medium eggs instead of large or jumbo so more will fit in the jar. Also, the pickle juice, or brine, permeates the smaller eggs more quickly, bringing them to their ideal flavor sooner than larger eggs. Fresh eggs keep longer but may be harder to peel once boiled, so allow eggs to age just a few days once they make it home from the store for easier peeling.

Fully cook and peel eggs before placing them in the brine for pickling. Place eggs in a saucepan and cover with water. Turn the burner on high and bring the water to a boil quickly then turn off the heat and cover the pan. Cook the eggs in the hot water for 12 to 15 minutes, depending on their size. Place the fully cooked eggs in an ice water bath to cool them quickly. Peel each egg starting at the large end and under cool running water to make it easier.

Once the eggs are boiled and peeled, add them to the pickle jar, taking care not to crowd. Each egg should have a cushion of brine surrounding it. Immediately refrigerate the jar of eggs and keep it stored in the refrigerator. Leave the eggs alone for at least two days before tasting them to let them soak up the brine. Eggs achieve more flavor over time, so waiting even longer yields a tastier result.

Without a rigorous commercial canning process, pickled eggs made at home can spoil. Store the boiled eggs in pickle juice in the refrigerator at all times and throw out leftovers after four weeks. Make sure eggs are fully cooked hard before placing the in the pickle juice. Soft boiled eggs won't yield the same result and may contain organisms that cause food borne illness.

About the Author

Andrea Lott is a career writer, performer and educator with an educational background in theater, classical studies and comedy. Her writing credits include articles, marketing materials and scripts. Lott studied theater and classical studies at IUPUI, and comedy writing and improv at Second City in Chicago.

Photo Credits

  • George Doyle/Stockbyte/Getty Images